A View of Lady Liberty
by Levi Ben-Shmuel
December 2004
Return to Writings

I had mixed feelings about moving back to New York after a twenty-year absence. The circumstances of my departure were not joyful. I had returned to the States after a magical eleven months in Israel in the fall of 1983. When I arrived at JFK and tasted the dirt, noise, grime and push of New York City, I felt that I had made the biggest mistake of my life in returning. It was truly by the grace of God that I crawled out of the deep depression I had sunk into at my parents’ house on Long Island and was able to start to live again a few months later in Boston.

Twenty years later I was newly married with a baby on the way and had no clear prospects for employment. On faith we had moved to Manhattan from California to be close to my family for the birth of our son. We were guided to find an apartment in Gramercy Park, a place neither of us knew. We found an apartment we both liked the first day out. The real estate agent believed in us so much that she said, “You would not have come to New York if you could not make it here. You will be ideal tenants. I am going to recommend to the landlord that they rent the apartment to you.” In a city where the norm for renting an apartment in a good neighborhood was to make four times the rent (which translated into a cool $100,000 per year salary), we found a real estate agent who convinced the landlords to rent the apartment to us on faith. Something was going on here…

A year later it was time to move again. The sixty steps to our third floor apartment in the charming brownstone on 18th St. were too much to navigate with a growing baby and all his paraphernalia. The intensity of Manhattan was getting to us as well. This time we were guided to look across the East River in Brooklyn. Our first day in Brooklyn found us in Prospect Park. We were amazed at the amount of space and sky. I felt comfortable in the area close to the park. Street after tree-lined street was filled with beautifully restored brownstones. After living in Gramercy Park I felt that I deserved to live in a place just as nice (if not nicer).

Heaven had other plans for me. On a cold, rainy December day a real estate agent guided us to a new building at the edge of Park Slope. As we drove down the main shopping avenue away from the park and the lovely tree-lined streets, the shops thinned out and boarded up, gutted buildings started to dot the landscape. I asked the agent, “Is this an okay neighborhood?” The life-long resident of Park Slope assured me that it was a solid, working-class area.

My mind and heart were not interested in looking at the seventh-floor, spotless apartment with unobstructed views to the south and west. The agent’s plug that the Statue of Liberty could be seen out of a bedroom window did nothing for me. As my wife happily went around the apartment figuring out where we could put our furniture, all I thought was, “No way! I am not living above a six-line highway!”*

Once again, I was proven wrong. After my wife pointed out to me that I was not open to what Heaven might have in mind for us, I was willing to go back and look again with an open mind and heart. This time I appreciated the building, the apartment and the amazing view of the Statue of Liberty out of our master bedroom window. We took the apartment.

I needed to drop my agenda about the kind of neighborhood and apartment that was “right” for me to live in. In fact, I needed to drop the idea that what was “right” for me was important at all. I was now a family man who was committed to putting the needs of his family first. The apartment met all our needs and was less rent than in Manhattan. I trusted that the neighborhood was good and safe, and that we would be happy there.

Every morning the first thing that I saw as I opened my eyes and looked out the window directly in front of me was the Statue of Liberty. No matter what the weather, she stood with her arm extended proclaiming the possibility of liberty for all who saw her. Many times throughout the day I would gaze at her and think of what she represented.

As the days, weeks and months rolled on I understood more and more that the liberty I craved was being free of self-imposed ideas and beliefs of who I was and what life owed me because of it. I was learning that there was another way to live that set me free of the box my mind and emotions had created inside of myself. Seeing the Statue of Liberty outside my window everyday was a constant reminder of the possibility to live a life free of the internal oppressions that seemed so much a part of who I really was.

I came to view our move to Brooklyn as an incredible gift. The neighborhood turned out to be fine. One by one the gutted, boarded up buildings were being transformed into airy, light-filled apartments. The mix of people in the area was a joy to be around. Seeing Lady Liberty everyday was a powerful reminder that I had more work to do to transform the boarded up places inside of myself into spacious, light-filled abodes of open-hearted liberty that were ready to embrace life and contribute to it for the good of my family and community.

Just as she inspired millions who gazed upon her as they entered New York Harbor for the first time, she continues to inspire me to break free of the chains of internal oppression, and to live my life with an open heart ready to appreciate and celebrate the goodness that continuously graces it.

*Prospect Avenue sits on one side of a six-lane great divide called the Prospect Expressway. It was built by the master builder of 20th century New York City and its suburbs, Robert Moses, in the 1950’s. The construction of the expressway tore apart neighborhoods throughout its 2.1 mile length.


Return to Writings
Reset
Up
Down